52% of Gen Z professionals don't want middle management, yet 64% of young people want to lead. How UK employers can redesign the role and rebuild the pipeline.
Link copied
The line manager pipeline is the supply of people ready and willing to take on a team for the first time. In many UK organisations it is thinning. Experienced managers are stretched, fewer early-career staff put their names forward, and first-line roles stay open longer or go to whoever is best at the technical job.
This piece is for UK HR, L&D and talent leads who fill first-line and middle manager roles. It sets out what the research says about willingness to manage, why the role looks unattractive from below, and four changes that make the pipeline work again. Executive succession is covered separately; this piece stays with the first and second rungs.
Younger employees still want to lead; what puts many of them off is the manager role as it is designed today. The two sets of findings below sit side by side.
| Finding | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
Gen Z professionals who don't want to be middle managers | 52% | Robert Walters UK poll, September 2024 |
Gen Z who would choose an individual route to progression over managing others | 72% | Robert Walters, September 2024 |
Gen Z who see middle management as "too high stress, low reward" | 69% | Robert Walters, September 2024 |
UK young people (18-24) who actively want to progress into management or leadership | 64% | CMI, Bridging the Gap, July 2026 (YouGov, 514 respondents) |
Employed young people who say it is important their line manager has been trained | 86% | CMI, July 2026 |
Young people who would feel much more confident stepping up with a formal mentor or professional body behind them | 83% | CMI, July 2026 |
Read together, the figures point at the deal on offer: more pressure, little extra reward and, in many organisations, no preparation.
The line manager role looks unattractive because junior staff watch their own managers carry it. Three patterns stand out.
Promotion without preparation. Earlier CMI research found that 82% of managers in the UK entered the role without formal management training. People are promoted for technical skill and learn to manage on the job, in front of the team.
Stress at the top of the pipeline too. DDI's leadership research reports that 71% of leaders are under increased stress and 40% have considered leaving their roles. The same work finds that 77% of CHROs lack confidence in their bench strength for critical roles.
Engagement is falling among managers. Gallup's State of the Global Workplace 2026 put global manager engagement at 22% in 2025, down from 27% a year earlier. Our piece on designing a leadership offsite around line managers covers what that means for teams.
A 26-year-old who sees a tired, untrained manager covering for gaps every week draws a reasonable conclusion about the job. That conclusion is where the pipeline problem starts.
Rebuilding the line manager pipeline means changing the role people are asked to step into, then preparing them before the promotion, while there is still time to practise. Four moves cover most of the ground.
| Move | What it looks like | What it answers |
|---|---|---|
Redesign the role | Clear span of control, fewer admin tasks, protected time for one-to-ones, and pay that reflects the extra responsibility | "Too high stress, low reward" |
Prepare before promotion | A short pre-manager programme for people who want to try it: delegating, feedback, difficult conversations | Promotion without training |
Support the first year | A mentor outside the reporting line, a peer cohort of new managers, a check-in at 90 days | The 83% who want a mentor behind them |
Keep two routes open | A senior individual route with the same standing as management, so nobody manages only to progress | The 72% who prefer an individual route |
The fourth move protects the other three. When management is the only way up, some people take the role who do not want it, and their teams feel the difference.
A speaker session fits at the start of a manager programme or a new-manager cohort, where it sets shared language and shows the role at its best. Its effect lasts when practice, mentoring and follow-up come after it.
Two placements work well:
1. Cohort launch. A keynote for everyone joining a pre-manager or first-year manager programme, followed by a workshop on one skill, such as feedback conversations.
2. Senior manager briefing. A session for the managers who will mentor the new cohort, on what the new generation expects from a trained manager.
Our guide to four formats and four different outcomes compares keynote, workshop, panel and fireside chat. When you brief the speaker, include who is in the room and what they will do afterwards; how to write the speaker brief covers the rest.
You'll find more names on our leadership speakers page.
Bill Benjamin on culture and the role of managers:
You know the line manager pipeline is improving when more first-line roles are filled from inside, by people who chose to apply, and when those new managers stay. Track four measures from your own data.
| Measure | How | When |
|---|---|---|
Internal fill rate | Share of first-line manager roles filled by internal candidates | Each quarter |
Expressed interest | Share of eligible staff who apply for the pre-manager programme or say in a career conversation that they want to manage | Twice a year |
First-year retention | Share of new managers still in a management role 12 months later | Annually |
Team feedback | Team questions such as "my manager gives me useful feedback", for teams of first-year managers | Before the programme and six months in |
If you also want a team climate measure, our psychological safety guide sets out a short scale. The early-career end of the pipeline is changing too: see what is happening to graduate hiring and entry-level work.
Many younger employees avoid manager roles because they see them as high pressure for little extra reward. In a 2024 Robert Walters poll, 52% of Gen Z professionals said they did not want to be middle managers and 69% called the role "too high stress, low reward".
Most young people in the UK still want to lead. CMI's July 2026 research found that 64% of 18 to 24-year-olds actively want to progress into management or leadership, and 86% of those in work said it matters that their line manager has been trained.
An accidental manager is someone promoted into a management role for their technical skill, without formal management training. CMI research found that 82% of managers in the UK entered the role this way.
Organisations make the line manager role more attractive by changing the role itself: a clear span of control, protected time for one-to-ones, pay that reflects the responsibility, preparation before promotion and a mentor in the first year. A senior individual route alongside management also helps.
A first-time manager programme should cover delegating, giving feedback and handling difficult conversations, and pair each new manager with a mentor and a peer cohort. CMI found that 83% of young people would feel much more confident stepping up with a formal mentor or professional body behind them.
Measure a line manager pipeline through internal fill rate for first-line roles, the share of eligible staff who say they want to manage, first-year manager retention and team feedback scores for new managers.
After Dinner Speakers
Contents
